Casey's Shadow (1978)

Martin Ritt's "Casey's Shadow" stands as a compelling testament to his mastery of character-driven storytelling and his nuanced exploration of American life. While perhaps not as universally lauded as some of his more iconic works, this 1978 film showcases Ritt's consistent ability to elicit powerful performances and create deeply felt narratives. The film's focus on the complex relationship between a father, his son, and their shared passion for a beloved horse allows Ritt to delve into themes of ambition, disappointment, and the enduring, sometimes fraught, bonds of family. His direction lends an authentic and grounded feel to the world of horse racing, imbuing even the grandest moments with a palpable sense of reality. What truly solidifies "Casey's Shadow" as a worthy inclusion in a list of Ritt's best is its signature blend of emotional depth and understated social commentary. Ritt avoids melodrama, instead opting for a more realistic portrayal of struggle and resilience. John C. McGinley delivers a wonderfully layered performance as the trainer, and Walter Matthau, often known for his comedic turns, offers a more restrained and affecting portrayal of a man wrestling with past glories and future uncertainties. The film's quiet power, its authentic depiction of human imperfection, and its ultimately poignant message about the pursuit of dreams make it a quintessential Martin Ritt film, deserving of its place among his finest works.