The One and Only (1978)

"The One and Only" (1978) is a charming and often hilarious comedy that chronicles the unconventional journey of Andy Schmidt (Henry Winkler), a charismatic college student in 1951. Andy, with his quick wit and a talent for delightful banter, manages to capture the affection of Mary (Kim Cattrall), despite her existing engagement. However, the real struggle begins after graduation when Andy finds the professional world less receptive to his unconventional approach to acting. This early struggle, marked by frustration and a need to make ends meet, leads him to an unexpected, and ultimately groundbreaking, career path. This film earns its spot on a list of "Best Carl Reiner Movies" for several key reasons. Reiner, known for his masterful blend of sharp dialogue and character-driven humor, brings out the best in Henry Winkler's performance, showcasing Andy's inherent likability and comedic timing. The narrative's exploration of an underdog finding his niche, even if it's through a seemingly absurd route like staged wrestling, resonates with Reiner's consistent ability to find comedy and heart in the everyday. Furthermore, the film's nostalgic setting and its commentary on artistic integrity and the challenges of a creative career offer layers of intelligence beneath the laughter, a hallmark of Reiner's directorial style.