Best Collectathon RPG games

Remember the sheer joy of combing every inch of a vibrant world, discovering hidden secrets, and powering up your hero with a treasure trove of collectibles? That's the unparalleled magic of collectathon RPGs, a genre that expertly blends the thrill of extensive exploration and item hoarding with deep character progression, epic narratives, and strategic combat. These games challenge our curiosity, reward our persistence, and leave us with a profound sense of accomplishment as we tick off every last objective and fill our inventory with wondrous artifacts. Today, we're embarking on the quest to classify the genre's titans using our definitive tier system: 'S' for the legendary, 'A' for the outstanding, 'B' for the solid, 'C' for the enjoyable, 'D' for the divisive, and 'E' for those that perhaps fell short of their potential. While we'll lay out our arguments, the real fun begins with you! Drag and drop each of the listed collectathon RPGs into your own 'S', 'A', 'B', 'C', 'D', or 'E' tiers below and share your ultimate ranking.